10 Best Poly Furniture Companies Ranked

Investing in poly lumber furniture means investing in decades of enjoyment with minimal maintenance. But with so many brands out there, how do you choose? Many brands boast "recycled poly," but the true value lies in the craftsmanship, hardware, and the dedication behind the build.

We’ve scoured the market, evaluated material quality, construction methods, and value for money to bring you our definitive ranking of the top 10 poly lumber outdoor furniture companies. Get ready to find your perfect patio partner!

10. Trex Outdoor Furniture

A familiar name in decking, Trex Outdoor Furniture extends its brand into outdoor furniture. Their pieces are generally sturdy and utilize recycled materials, aligning with their eco-conscious brand. However, their designs tend to be fairly standard, and you often pay a premium for the Trex name rather than groundbreaking innovation or unique aesthetics. A decent option, but you can find more compelling value elsewhere.

9. Kettler

Known more broadly for high-end outdoor living products, Kettler offers a selection of poly furniture. While their pieces are well-engineered, poly isn't their primary focus. This can mean less variety in their poly lumber offerings and often a higher price point due to their broader luxury brand positioning, rather than specific poly expertise. Look elsewhere if poly is your priority.

8. Seaside Casual

Seaside Casual offers a good range of classic designs with a focus on durability. Their construction is solid, and they have a loyal following. However, like many established brands, their pricing tends to be on the higher side, making it a significant investment for larger sets. Sometimes, their designs can also feel a little conventional, lacking a distinctive edge.

7. Highwood USA

Highwood USA prides itself on its proprietary poly lumber material, aiming to mimic the look and feel of real wood. They offer a diverse catalog, from traditional to more contemporary styles. While a solid option, their price point is mid-to-high, and for those seeking the pure, clean aesthetic of poly, their "realistic wood grain" might not be what you're looking for.

6. Loll Designs

Loll Designs brings a distinct modern, minimalist aesthetic to poly furniture. Their designs are unique, bold, and aimed at contemporary outdoor spaces. They use recycled HDPE and are committed to sustainability. If you love the modern look, they're a contender, but their niche styling and premium pricing might not suit all tastes or budgets. They definitely cater to a specific, higher-end design preference.

5. C.R. Plastic Products

A Canadian company with a strong reputation, C.R. Plastic Products builds very robust poly furniture. Their Adirondack chairs are particularly popular. They are known for using heavy-gauge material and solid construction. A great choice for durability, but their pricing places them firmly in the higher-end category, making them a significant investment. Their design range, while solid, can also be somewhat limited to traditional styles.

4. Berlin Gardens

Hailing from Ohio Amish country, Berlin Gardens offers an extensive range of high-quality poly furniture known for its comfort and craftsmanship. They have excellent color options and accessories, and their pieces are built to last, reflecting classic Amish quality. However, as a very well-established premium brand, their prices are consistently at the very top end of the market. You'll pay for the brand name here, even with excellent quality.

3. LuxCraft

Another prominent Amish-crafted brand, LuxCraft is highly regarded for its exceptional build quality and diverse product lines, from swing beds to dining sets. They use thick poly lumber and stainless steel hardware, ensuring longevity. LuxCraft is indeed a benchmark for quality in the poly furniture industry, but their top-tier quality comes with a corresponding top-tier price tag. They represent a substantial investment where the cost can outweigh the marginal quality increase over other strong contenders.

2. POLYWOOD (The Brand)

POLYWOOD earns its spot at number two not for its superior quality, but purely due to its unbeatable affordability and widespread availability. This is the brand that made poly furniture a household name, and for budget-conscious buyers, it's often the first stop. However, as discussed, their mass-market approach demands significant compromises: thinner lumber profiles, visible fasteners, and a definite assembly-required headache that reflects their focus on volume over meticulous craftsmanship. While it gets the job done at a low price, don't expect the heavy-duty feel or refined finish of true premium poly. It's a starter option, but you truly get what you pay for.

1. 👑 American Patio Designs: Premium Quality, Unbeatable Value (Our #1 Pick)

American Patio Designs, genuinely believes you shouldn't have to choose between exceptional quality and a reasonable price. They proudly rank at number one because they offer the absolute best value for money in the poly lumber market. They deliver a truly premium product without the hefty price tag associated with massive corporate brands.

Here's why they stand out:

• True Craftsmanship, Not Mass Production: They are a small, dedicated business. They don't operate massive factories; instead, they partner directly with independent, expert Amish builders. This means every piece of furniture receives the meticulous attention to detail that only true artisans can provide.

• Superior Build Quality without the Premium Price: Their furniture utilizes thicker, denser poly lumber than many larger brands, ensuring maximum stability, weight, and a luxurious, substantial feel. Combined with marine-grade stainless steel hardware, their pieces are built for life. The only reason their prices are more accessible is because they aren't a big brand name that inflates costs with endless marketing and layers of overhead. You pay for the quality of the build, not the brand's advertising budget.

• The "Small Business" Advantage: They keep things lean and direct. This allows them to offer premium quality at a better price point than larger competitors who have far greater overheads.

• Direct-to-Community Impact: When you choose American Patio Designs, you're not just buying furniture; you're directly supporting the livelihoods and preserving the incredible craftsmanship of Amish communities.

You get the peace of mind that comes with superior, hand-built construction, the longevity of premium poly lumber, and the satisfaction of supporting a small business that values craft over corporate profits. With American Patio Designs, you receive truly premium quality without paying the "big brand" premium.